European dairy industry is suffering a deep crisis during the last months due the low prices of sale, under the production costs.
According to the European Commission, the crisis has been driven by the Russia's trade ban on Community food industry, added a demand fall of milky products in China P.R. and other BRICS countries to a lesser extend, and a slight increase of the world production especially emphasizing Australia (2.5 %), USA (1.6 %), New Zealand, world's largest producer, (0.9 %) y the European Union (0.8 %).
Summarizing, there has been a temporary drop in demand joined a slight increase of production.
The practical impact is the milk price is between 15 % and 35 % (depends on the EU area) under a price to give profitability enough to the producers.
What solutions can be applied?
Both, the dairy producer associations and European Union govermments propose the following measures:
- Setting minimum retail prices.
- Re-introduction of production quotas.
- Financial grant, to compensate the drop of profitability.
- Encourage innovation and develop of new dairy products, to consume the milk production.
- Creation of new cooperatives and associations, to apply economy of scale.
Innovation and develop of new dairy products is an excellent solution, it must be carry out at all times, but due its high risk, high cost and high period of phasing, it doesn´t look the best short-term solution.
Creation of cooperatives and associations will reduce costs and increase efficiencies, but supposes a short-time staff reduction by duplicities elimination.
About setting prices, re-introduction of quotas and financial grants, they don't suppose an improvement of producer's productivity, so the producers will be grants dependant and will lost market share.
An engineering solution.
We can define productivity as a ratio of outputs (milk production) and inputs (resources needed for the production).
Productivity = Actual Outputs / Actual Inputs
Let's analyze each term.
Actual Outputs: It's the result to multiplying production Capacity, Availability of the process (ratio of gross operating time and available production time), Performance of the process (ratio of net operating time and gross operating time), and Quality of the process (ratio of valuable operating time and net operating time).
In accordance with Lean Manufacturing methodology, the result of multiplying Availability, Performance and Quality is defined as Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE):
Actual Outputs = Capacity * OEE
Actual Inputs: It's the result of the addition of human resources and physical resources; physical resources are the addition of Acquisition Costs, Operation Costs, Maintenance Costs and Disposal Costs.
Resources = Human Resources + Acquisition Costs + Operation Costs + Maintenance Costs + Disposal Costs
Therefore, to improve productivity is possible by the OEE increase, Acquisition, Operation, Maintenance and Disposal Costs; without increase the Capacity or reduce Labor Force Costs.
To implant Lean policies, as Value Stream Mapping and pull system to eliminate wastes, to increase availability by Kanban and reduce human errors by Poka Yoke allow increasing dramatically the real production without big capital investments.
On the other hand, to implant a Physical Asset Management plan allows the physical resources optimization by implanting specific measures as Reliability Assurance programs and Reliability Centered Maintenance (RCM), taking into consideration the implantation risk.
A sustainable solution.
The implantation of both Lean and Physical Asset Management results a quick rise of productivity, without the need of large investment, without reduce labor force, and controlling the risk associated.
It provides a sustainable solution because it is focused in reducing costs; consequently it increases competitiveness, at the same time increases production, and allows to rise the market share and business profitability, releasing resources that may dedicate themselves to research, development and innovation.